Turning FCAS Into a Revenue Stream: How IPPs Can Profit from Grid Instability

As Australia transitions into a renewable-dominated energy market, Independent Power Producers (IPP’s) are standing at a pivotal crossroads. The challenges of grid instability, frequency volatility, and increasing compliance demands are clear. Yet, so is the opportunity to turn these challenges into lucrative advantages.

Once dismissed as a regulatory necessity and cost, Frequency Control Ancillary Services (FCAS) have emerged as a viable and significant revenue stream. The numbers tell a powerful story: FCAS markets have expanded at an astonishing pace—from AU$5 million in 2014 to AU$65 million in just two years1, with Queensland alone incurring AU$234 million in FCAS costs in 20212. These are not just abstract figures—they represent a monumental opportunity for IPPs equipped to respond to the grid’s needs.

This figure shows the quarterly average enablement amount for each FCAS service across the NEM for the past five years. These include average enablement amount for both raise and lower regulation services, and raise and lower contingency services (fast - 6 second, slow - 60 second, delayed - 5 minute). SourceAER; AEMOAER reference: 11048184
This figure shows the quarterly average enablement amount for each FCAS service across the NEM for the past five years. These include average enablement amount for both raise and lower regulation services, and raise and lower contingency services (fast – 6 second, slow – 60 second, delayed – 5 minute). Source: AER; AEMO. AER reference: 11048184.

The key lies in leveraging the right technology to address these challenges while optimising contingency FCAS participation. Enter the VECTO System, a state-of-the-art combination of VECTO 3 hardware and its accompanying FCAS module. This system redefines the way IPPs approach frequency management, turning technical hurdles into avenues of growth and profitability.

What is FCAS?

The power system must maintain balance between electricity generation and use at all times. When demand exceeds supply, system frequency drops. When supply exceeds demand, frequency rises. In Australia, if frequency moves outside 47-52Hz, the system will shut down to prevent equipment damage, leading to blackouts like the South Australia event in September 2016. AEMO‘s key role is to prevent these disruptions by keeping generation and demand in balance.

FCAS help maintain this critical balance. FCAS providers can quickly adjust their power output or consumption to help keep the system frequency at 50Hz/60Hz. These services work in two ways: regulation FCAS makes small, continuous adjustments, while contingency FCAS responds to sudden, major changes in the system. This creates a stable and reliable power network.

The Grid at a Tipping Point: Challenges and Opportunities for IPPs

Australia’s energy market is undergoing a seismic shift. As traditional, rotational-inertia-heavy power sources are replaced by Inverter Based Resource (IBR) based renewables, the grid’s ability to self-stabilise is weakening. The result? A rapid increase in the Rate of Change of Frequency (RoCoF) following disruptions, with frequency deviations becoming deeper (nadirs) and faster.

For IPPs, this presents two opposing realities:

  1. The Challenge: Grid instability increases the likelihood of disconnections, curtailment, and revenue loss. Compliance requirements for FCAS participation are stringent, demanding precise measurement, reporting, and rapid response capabilities that strain many existing systems.
  2. The Opportunity: These very instabilities have made contingency FCAS a critical tool for grid management, and providers of fast, reliable frequency support stand to gain significant revenue. In 2020 alone, grid-connected batteries (BESS) earned in the region of AU$50 million in FCAS revenue during separation events3—a testament to the financial potential of participating in ancillary services.

Why FCAS Is a Goldmine for IPPs

Historically, FCAS has accounted for only 1-2% of total energy costs. But as grid dynamics evolve, this figure has risen sharply. By Q1 2020, FCAS accounted for 8% of total energy costs, translating to AU$310 million in system costs. For IPPs, this is a clear signal: the demand for frequency control services is real (and profitable4).

Specific instances underscore this growing opportunity:

  • Queensland’s Solar Curtailment: In 2019/20, 178 GWh of generation capacity was curtailed, with 97 GWh of this economically driven. With precise frequency support and advanced monitoring, IPPs could have mitigated these losses and turned curtailment into revenue opportunities.
  • Very Fast FCAS (VF FCAS): The introduction of VF FCAS, which demands near-instantaneous response times, has opened up an entirely new market segment. This represents both a challenge and a lucrative frontier for IPPs capable of meeting these stringent requirements.
Australian BESS Very Fast FCAS Revenue by Participant: 9-19th October.

Addressing Barriers: Why Many IPPs Struggle to Access FCAS Markets

Despite its potential, many IPPs find themselves sidelined from FCAS markets. The reasons are clear:

  • Complex Compliance Requirements: Manual processes for collecting and verifying data, correlating timestamps, and generating reports are labor-intensive and prone to errors.
  • High Technical Standards: Contingency FCAS participation demands precision in monitoring, reporting, and response, with stringent requirements for accuracy and speed.
  • Operational Inefficiencies: Without streamlined systems, engineering teams are forced to devote significant hours to compliance rather than optimising performance.

These challenges create a barrier to entry that prevents many IPPs from fully capitalising on the contingency FCAS opportunity.

The VECTO Solution: Precision, Simplicity, and Profitability

The VECTO System is a step-change improvement for IPPs navigating the complexities of contingency FCAS participation. Combining cutting-edge hardware (VECTO 3) with intelligent software (VECTO Grid OS), and the Contingency FCAS module, it transforms the way IPPs approach frequency control.

Key Features of the VECTO System

  1. Industry-Leading Precision:
    • High-resolution monitoring with 1.5 MHz sampling and 50 kHz waveform storage ensures visibility into even the smallest frequency deviations.
    • Intrinsic uncertainty of less than 0.01 Hz simultaneously meets and exceeds the FCAS required IEEE C37-118 Class P & M standards.
  2. Automation at Its Core:
    • Automated FCASVT-compliant reporting eliminates the need for manual data collection, correlation and complex calculations.
    • SCADA integration capabilities enables real-time visibility and comprehensive performance monitoring and response.
  3. Seamless Integration:
    • Real-time event detection ensures immediate SCADA integrated response mechanisms to grid fluctuations, maximising profitability during critical events.
    • Integration with existing systems ensures minimal disruption while enhancing operational efficiency.

Real-World Impact: How VECTO Empowers IPPs

During grid separation events, facilities equipped with the VECTO System not only met compliance requirements but also captured revenue by responding with precision and speed. This success highlights the transformative potential of combining advanced technical capabilities with automated processes.

For example:

  • Grid Curtailment Mitigation: With VECTO, IPPs can identify curtailment risks in real-time and proactively deliver frequency support, converting lost generation opportunities into revenue.
  • VF FCAS Leadership: By exceeding the technical requirements for Very Fast FCAS, VECTO users can confidently participate in this high-value market segment, setting themselves apart from competitors.

The Path Forward: Turning Challenges into Opportunities

The Australian energy market is at an inflection point, and the message to IPPs is clear: the grid’s challenges are your opportunities. With FCAS costs soaring and new markets like VF FCAS emerging, the potential for revenue growth is significant.

The VECTO System provides the tools to not only navigate but thrive in this dynamic environment. By automating compliance and claim submission, enhancing precision, and enabling seamless market participation, VECTO transforms FCAS from a regulatory hurdle and cost into a high-margin revenue stream.

A Call to Action: Seize the FCAS Opportunity

The future belongs to agile, forward-thinking IPPs willing to invest in the technology needed to adapt to a renewable-powered grid. The VECTO System offers more than just compliance—it offers a competitive edge.

The opportunity is here. Are you ready to seize it?

Sources:

Australian Wholesale electricity market performance report 2022
AEMO Service Commencement Plan P2267 Fast Frequency Response (FFR)

  1. https://www.aer.gov.au/industry/registers/charts/quarterly-global-fcas-prices-services?t ↩︎
  2. https://www.griffith.edu.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0033/1639356/No.2021-01-Renewable-Energy-Zones.pdf?t ↩︎
  3. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hornsdale_Power_Reserve#Revenues_from_operation ↩︎
  4. https://reneweconomy.com.au/neoen-aims-for-big-batteries-in-every-state-following-success-of-tesla-big-battery/ ↩︎

Related Posts

VECTO System - Power engineers monitoring Sub-Synchronous Control Interactions in an electrical sub-station.

Tackling Sub-Synchronous Control Interactions: Ensuring Grid Stability in the Era of Renewable Energy Integration

This article delves into SSCI impact on frequency stability, compliance, and the risk of operational curtailment due to power quality. As renewable energy resources expand, inverter-connected installations like Utility-Scale Wind Power Sites and Commercial Solar Energy Infrastructure bring a risk of sub-synchronous control interactions (SSCI). These low-frequency oscillations, arising from interactions between inverters and compensating devices, challenge grid stability and asset lifespan.

Harmonic impedance scanning is a powerful analytical technique used in electrical power systems to evaluate system behavior across a range of frequencies. This method is particularly useful for identifying resonance conditions and assessing the impact of harmonics on the quality of supply (Power Quality (PQ)).

Harmonic Impedance Scanning

Harmonic impedance scanning is a powerful analytical technique used in electrical power systems to evaluate system behavior across a range of frequencies. This method is particularly useful for identifying resonance conditions and assessing the impact of harmonics on the quality of supply (Power Quality (PQ)).

VECTO System - Electric Grid Sub-synchronous Oscillations

Case Study: Small Signal Spectrum Capturing

Explore the innovative approach to capturing small signal oscillations (SSO’s) in the West Murray Zone using VECTO System’s advanced tools. This compelling case study reveals how high-resolution EMT data and GPS-synchronised algorithms enhance grid stability analysis, overcoming the limitations of conventional PMUs. Ideal for power system engineers and consultants, discover how these edge-computing based grid technologies provide accurate, reliable data for effective grid stability management. Read more to learn about this breakthrough in power system stability monitoring.